Skip to main content

Lake Avery Enlargement

Handout for Tour of Lake Avery for BRT on July 8, 2026

Prepared by Bailey Franklin – CPW District Wildlife Manager and YJWCD Board Member

   

CPW Dam Rehabilitation/Maintenance Work and Refill Status for Lake Avery

  • Lake Avery is classified as a High Hazard Dam, meaning if the dam fails it would cause significant losses downstream; it was constructed between 1964-1966; dam is 90 feet high with crest length of 620 feet; outlet structure is 36” pipe with hydraulic slide gate and max capacity of 260 cfs; spillway has max. capacity of 975 cfs.
  • Lake Avery has a current maximum capacity of 7,658 acre-feet (218 surface acres). CPW’s water right in Lake Avery (Priority #726; App. Date of 6/27/1968) is decreed for fisheries, waterfowl, recreation.
  • Annual dam inspections showed fairly major issues that required CPW to drain Lake Avery in summer/fall of 2024 in order to repair the dam to meet state public dam safety requirements. CPW hired a contractor, American West Construction, in 2025 to repair safe operation of the dam’s outlet works, toe drain system, and irrigation water diversion delivery system. The required dam safety construction work was completed in March of 2026 by contractor, including but not limited to: new concrete inlet and outlet structures; new concrete stem wall from inlet structure to the dam crest; relining of the outlet pipe/conduit that runs through the dam; replaced water flow/delivery system with new hydraulic gates that can accurately measure and control any water that is released from Lake Avery into the White River; replacement of toe drains and irrigation diversion system at base of dam.
  • CPW received approval from DWR to close the hydraulic gates in the dam and begin refilling Lake Avery on March 20, 2026. Due to the calls on the White River, CPW was only able to get approximately 32-feet of water stored in Lake Avery thus far in 2026 (approx. 700 acre-feet or 11% of total reservoir capacity.
  • CPW is planning to stock fingerling cutthroat trout into Lake Avery in September, 2026 to begin rebuilding the fishery with hopes that the reservoir can be completely filled if conditions allow by summer of 2027.
  • CPW has a 5-in-10 year water loan agreement with CWCB that allows CPW to release water from Lake Avery and into White River to maintain instream flow rights and protect fishery (up to 3,000 acre-feet/year).

Status of Proposal to Enlarge Lake Avery in Future by YJWCD along with other funding partners/stakeholders

  • YJWCD has been working collaboratively with CPW since 2015 to secure permission and support to potentially expand water storage capacity within Lake Avery. CPW has provided formal letters of support to YJWCD for this effort.
  • On March 30, 2022, YJWCD formally received legal right to store their 10,000 acre feet of Sawmill Mountain Reservoir conditional water rights in Lake Avery (Water Court Case No. 19CW3017 w/ appropriation date of 10/7/1976), to be used for municipal, industrial, agricultural, domestic, recreational, augmentation and piscatorial uses within and below Lake Avery. YJWCD has until March, 2028, to meet the due diligence requirements for this water right.
  • Water storage capacity and flows in upper White River Valley have been identified as major limiting factors to downstream water users as a result of: frequent droughts; calls placed on the White River by RBWCD starting in December, 2022; and the designation of the White River basin by CO DWR as over-appropriated in May, 2025.
  • Lake Avery was identified by Applegate/YJWCD as the most realistic and beneficial location for a water storage project within the upper White River drainage. Therefore, the proposed expansion of Lake Avery is YJWCD’s top priority.
  • An expansion of Lake Avery would allow YJWCD to utilize its Sawmill Mountain conditional water right to supply water for a variety of beneficial purposes to benefit all water users within the YJWCD district.
  • CPW is currently considering development of a water augmentation plan for the White River Valley in collaboration with both RBWCD and YJWCD, which is very exciting.
  • YJWCD is currently working collaboratively with Rio Blanco County and Colorado River District to raise a total of $257,000 in order to hire AECOM to complete an engineering feasibility study in 2026-2027 for the Lake Avery Enlargement proposal. Grant funding is expected to be awarded to YJWCD by RBC and CRD for the Lake Avery enlargement engineering feasibility study by early August, 2026. The engineering feasibility study will evaluate two enlargement options for Lake Avery: 1) modify existing spillway on the dam to maximize reservoir water storage capacity without enlargement of the dam embankment; 2) enlarge the dam embankment and modify the spillway structures in order to provide up to 10,000 acre-feet of additional water storage. Factors that AECOM will be required to consider for the feasibility study include: water rights; geotechnical evaluation; spillway evaluation; outlet evaluation; impacts to existing infrastructure; permitting; and overall cost/feasibility of expansion scenarios.

Potential Benefits of Enlarging Water Storage Capacity in Lake Avery

  • Benefit local community and water users by providing a source of badly needed augmentation water for non-agricultural, domestic, industrial, municipal augmentation purposes now that White River has been designated as over-appropriated above the Taylor Draw Dam.
  • Benefit local community and economy in Rio Blanco County by protecting the sustainability and health of the White River Valley.
  • Benefit to local agricultural producers and irrigation companies directly or indirectly by preventing calls on the White River during peak irrigation season.
  • Provide CPW with more flexibility to release water out of Lake Avery in order to sustain critical instream flows in cooperation with CWCB, and protect aquatic habitat/fisheries within the critical reach of the upper White River (from confluence of Big Beaver Creek down to confluence with Coal Creek) during drought years.
  • Allow for additional fishery resources, aquatic habitat, and public recreation within Lake Avery seasonally.

Potential Negative Consequences of Enlarging Water Storage Capacity in Lake Avery

  • CPW would be taking on additional liability from dam maintenance and public dam safety standpoint, which is not appealing at all to the agency
  • CPW (or another entity like YJWCD) would have to hire a full time project manager to manage and implement water releases, etc., from an expanded Lake Avery in the future, which is also not appealing to the agency.
  • There would be potential for an aesthetically ugly bathtub ring around the perimeter of Lake Avery due to water level fluctuations associated with annual water releases (of up to 10,000 acre feet), which could also impact boat ramps, campgrounds, parking areas, fishing docks, upstream private landowners, etc.
  • Cost and feasibility of an enlargement of Lake Avery is yet to be determined, and funding partners may be limited.
  • CPW will have ultimate control and final approval over any future plan that is developed to potentially enlarge Lake Avery, and CPW is not willing to allocate any funding or employee/labor towards an enlargement at this time.